Dim Gets Ridiculously Dimmer

Geese come in gaggles, bass in shoals and a crowd of crows is called a murder. Likewise, there are names for groups of stars. They come in constellations, globular clusters, dwarf galaxies and galaxies, just to name a few.

With the exception of constellations (which are just chance alignments of unrelated stars), all these are groups of stars are distinguished from each other by such things as the number of stars, the mass of the entire group and how well the group is holding together ? the kind of stuff astronomers sort out by measuring the distances and speeds of stars. Seems like pretty unexciting stuff, until something strange pops up. And in astronomy, something strange pops up a lot.

Here is the latest case: In the process of surveying dwarf galaxies orbiting the Milky Way galaxy, a team of American, Canadian and Chilean astronomers stumbled onto a remarkably faint cluster of stars out there in the galactic hinterlands. The globular cluster, called Mu?oz 1, puts out as much light as only 120 modest Sun-like stars and was discovered near a previously known dwarf galaxy using the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) and confirmed using the Keck II Telescope.

?What?s neat about this is it?s the dimmest globular cluster ever found,? said Ricardo Mu?oz, an astronomer at the University of Chile and the discoverer of the cluster. A globular cluster is a spherical group of stars bound to each other by gravity so that they orbit around a galaxy as a unit.

?While I was working on the Ursa Minor dwarf galaxy I noticed there was this tiny little object close by,? Mu?oz recalled. He made the discovery while he was a postdoctoral associate at Yale University. Most globular clusters have in the range of 100,000 stars. Mu?oz 1 has something like 500 stars. ?This is very surprising,? he said.

?It?s ridiculously dim,? agreed Yale astronomer Marla Geha. ?There are individual stars that would far outshine this entire globular cluster.? That puts Mu?oz 1 head-to-head with the Segue 3 globular cluster (also orbiting the Milky Way) as the dimmest troupe of old stars ever found.

Mu?oz 1?s discovery was the result of a survey done with the CFHT MegaCam imager in 2009 and 2010. It was then confirmed by spectroscopic study using the Deep Extragalactic Imaging Multi-Object Spectrograph (DEIMOS) on the Keck II telescope. The researchers will be publishing their results soon in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.

Keck Observatory data was critical for the study, said Geha, because it sorted out whether or not Mu?oz 1 and the Ursa Minor dwarf galaxy were moving together.

?Nearly every galaxy has an entourage of globular clusters,? said Geha, ?so we first thought that Mu?oz 1 might be associated with the nearby Ursa Minor dwarf galaxy.? By using spectroscopic data to measure the relative velocities of the cluster and the dwarf galaxy, they discovered quite the opposite was the case.

?The velocities turned out to be wildly different,? said Geha. So the fact that they are near each other is just a coincidence, she said. What has been seen is more like a single snapshot of two cars traveling near each other and apparently together, but they really have different destinations and are traveling at very different speeds. Analysis of the brightness and colors of the stars belonging to Mu?oz 1 and Ursa Minor also suggests that the tiny cluster is actually located about 100,000 light years in front of the dwarf galaxy.

As for how Mu?oz 1 came to be so dim, a likely scenario is that it has gradually lost stars over the eons, said Geha. It?s also possible it was stripped of stars by passing through the Milky Way. But the direction of the cluster?s movement is not yet known, so it?s not known whether it has passed through the Milky Way.

Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of the discovery is the possibility that Mu?oz 1 may be hinting that there are many more such globular clusters in the Galactic halo. After all, the CFHT survey covered only 40 square degrees of sky out of 40,000 square degrees in the entire sky.

?Assuming that we?re not just lucky to have found something very rare, there could be many others out there,? said Geha.

?To truly understand its nature, we will need to measure its mass,? added Munoz. To do that, astronomers would need to measure the velocities of individual stars in the cluster and see how they move with relation to each other. That, in turn, reveals the overall mass of the cluster. A lot of mass would suggest there is a lot of dark matter holding the cluster together, and maybe even qualify the cluster as the smallest, darkest galaxy ever discovered. Right now the Segue 1 dwarf galaxy holds that record. Geha was also involved in measurements with the Keck DEIMOS instrument that confirmed the nature of Segue 1.

?The goal of this survey was to understand the difference between dwarf galaxies and globular clusters,? said Geha. The discovery of Mu?oz 1 suggests there may be plenty of odd collections of stars out there, challenging the vocabularies of astronomers and just waiting to be found.


Filter by year OR type:

View all


We are setting up HIRESR on Keck 1 for CIT observers, NIRSPEC/NIRC2-NGS on Keck 2 for NASA observers. Sun set 07:09:00pm rise 05:48:00am
UCB observers will work with HIRESR tonight. And NASA/UCSD observers will work with NIRSPEC/NIRC2-NGS. Sun set 07:09:00pm rise 05:47:00am
Congratulations Andrea Ghez @UCLA and #GalacticCenter team! Love, W. M. Keck Observatory bit.ly/1DWqDI0
SCIENCE NEWS: Astronomers @keckobservatory & @NASA_Hubble use microlensing to find Uranus-sizd #exoplanet bit.ly/1DcPixb
Our guests tonight are observers from NASA and CIT-Y, using HIRESR and NIRC2-LGS respectively. Sun set 07:11:00pm rise 05:46:00am